Complete Financial Questionnaire

Why Buying Mortgage Protection from a Bank is a Bad Idea


It’s very easy to think that bankers are wan…bad guys.

Sure wasn’t it the bank’s fault that The Boom collapsed so badly?

Younger readers might be thinking

what Boom?

It was waaaaaaaaay back in 2008 after all.

Between massive loans and inflated prices, it was all a bit of a disaster.

Now we’ve sort of returned to a middle ground where the banks aren’t such bad guys after all.

Or have we?

When it comes to Mortgage Protection, that’s definitely not the case.


Let’s take a look at why buying insurance with a bank will hit you square in the pocket.

Buying Mortgage Protection from a Bank

If you’re looking for financial advice, your bank may seem like a safe bet.

You probably already trust them with your wages– unless you’re one of those people who keeps all their cash in a shoebox buried in their shed.

And you’ll use your bank to get a mortgage when you join the rat race and buy your first home.

Although this could change as the Credit Union plans to shake up the market (paywall)

So I understand why your bank makes sense as your choice for Life Insurance (or Income Protection or Mortgage Protection).

You wander into your local branch, stand around for a few minutes, talk to someone, and get started on the process.

Most of the time, the bank will offer you cover there and then.

They will only turn you down if they think the chances of you claiming are too high.

The insurers (and banks) want to make money and the best way to do that is by betting on people who will outlive their policy.

The safest bet is someone young and healthy, so if you fit that category your policy application will fly through.

However, if you have an underlying condition, it gets more complicated and your fate is determined by underwriters, who calculate your risk of claiming.

What if the Bank Turns Your Down?

If you’re turned down by your bank, that doesn’t mean you’re an insurance black zone where nothing can prosper.

You may just need to take your trade elsewhere.

Even if you’re accepted by your bank, you should take your trade elsewhere too.


I’ll let you in on a little secret: there are seven insurers in Ireland and the banks only work with two of them.

If you do the maths on that, you can see why you’re probably not getting the best deal.

Enter stage left: the broker.

Reasons for Using a Broker

Let’s get this out of the way: I’m a broker.

I’m obviously biased but – and this is the big one – I work with five of the seven insurers (we don’t work with Laya or Acorn)

Straight out of the gates, I have a better chance of getting you a better deal because we deal with more providers than the bank.

Which leads nicely round to impartiality.

We don’t have any particular favourites when it comes to insurers but must say Royal London is doing a fine job so they get a fair whack of the straightforward mortgage protection applications.

However, around 50% of our customers have quirky health issues hence we spread our business amongst all of the providers (even Irish Life!)

Where We Placed Our Business Last Year

Here’s the breakdown of where we insured our clients last year:

top life insurance providers in Ireland 2024


Did you know we’re the only life insurance broker that publishes these figures annually?

What have the others got to hide?


Are Banks Good for People with Health Conditions?

And, if you’ve got a chronic illness, I’m your best bet as I can match you with the insurer who is most sympathetic to your illness.

If you’ve got a chronic illness and you go to a bank for insurance…well, you may end up with the least sympathetic insurance provider and a letter of decline in the post or you might get hit with a massive loading.

As well as getting you covered at the lowest price, a broker can also advise on the best insurer for each type of cover.

Let’s say you go to a bank: they’ll offer you Mortgage Protection from Irish Life, Serious Illness Cover from Irish Life, Life Insurance from Irish Life, and you guessed it…Income Protection from Irish Life.


Because, as I mentioned, most banks only deal with Irish Life.

(Bank of Ireland only deal with Bank of Ireland Life.)

Do Brokers Offer Better Perks?

So if you go with your bank, you’re missing out on valuable benefits such as:

Finally, here’s the kicker, if you add Serious Illness Cover to your Mortgage Protection policy, the bank will get the pay-out.

I’ll bet the bank didn’t tell you that.

Dealing with an insurance broker means you’ll clearly understand exactly what you’re getting, any risks involved, and what’s actually covered in your policy.

Of course, there’s also the option of going directly to the insurance companies themselves but I guarantee that you’ll get ripped off.

Who Has the Lower Prices?

Let’s do a little comparison.

Susan is 40. She doesn’t smoke and is in good health.

She’d like a 30-year term on €500,000 cover with the option of extending the cover when she’s older without having to answer health questions.

Her quote looks like this:


She’ll probably choose Zurich.

If she’d gone to the banks, she’d only be given one option, Irish Life.

Over 30 years, this would cost her €7,776 more in premiums!

After Sales Service

For me this is huge.

We, and most advisors, pride ourselves on customer service.

Unlike the banks where you are just a number, we build a relationship with our clients so when they need help in the future, they come back to us.

And if they ever need to amend their policy, we can do it for them.

If you buy from the bank, I’m afraid you’re going to be stuck in that bloody pre-recorded phone tree if you need to contact anyone.

Hello and welcome to Bank of Ireland. For the next 3 minutes, I’m going to tell you to go online. then I’m going to give you 6 options, none of which are correct. Then you can press # to start again.

FFS Just let me press 1 to avoid this stupid phone tree

Use a small broker (like us) and you get a direct number for me or one of our team!

Still Considering Buying Mortgage Protection from a Bank?

Using a broker can provide you with more choice, personalised advice, and dedicated support throughout the process.

On the other hand, getting life insurance through a bank might be more convenient if you prefer managing all your financial products in one place, but it will come with fewer options and higher premiums.

Ultimately though, the crucial aspect is to choose someone you can trust, whether it’s a broker or a banker.

There are shyster brokers and shyster bankers so be on your toes.

Be sure to compare policies, understand the terms and conditions, and select a policy that protects you and your family from the bad stuff life can throw at you.

If you’d like me to help, complete this questionnaire, and I’ll be right back.

You can trust us.

Thanks for reading,

Nick | Protection Broker of the Year 🏆

life_insurance_schedule_a _call

Life Insurance
Give us a quick outline of how we can help and we'll be right back to you.

How Digestive Disorders Impact Life Insurance

In this guide, we'll dive into the world of digestive disorders and how they can affect your life insurance and mortgage protection.

We'll chat about seven common digestive issues, like Barrett's oesophagus, Gastro‑oesophageal reflux, and those pesky hernias.

I'll spill the beans on what insurers want to know, how it impacts your costs, and whether you're eligible for serious illness or income protection coverage.

So, grab a cuppa, relax, and let's make sense of it all.

Don’t know where to start?

Have a nose through our free life insurance guides

View our guides

Life Insurance Quotes - Free and Easy!

As Ireland's leading life insurance broker, we specialise in comparing the rates and policies from the top five Irish life insurance providers and offering the very best value quotes to suit the individual needs of our clients. Our expertise lies in finding a suitable insurance plan for those with specific needs, be it a particular illness, occupation or claim history, we've got you covered in every sense!

Watch our video